Get Your FREE Weekly Meal Planner Here

Get it NOW!

GSFF

  • Start Here
  • Budgeting
  • Organization
  • Making Money
  • Shop
  • Free Printables
  • About
You are here: Home / Recipes / Tomato and Onion Pie Recipe
 Post may contain affiliate links. Click to read Disclosure . Click to read Privacy Policy. 

Tomato and Onion Pie Recipe

in Recipes, Side Dishes on 02/18/22

  •  shares
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Flipboard
  • Twitter
Tomato and Onion Pie!

 Tomato and Onion Pie

Susan is back and today she has chosen a really tasty Tomato and Onion Pie! 

I chose this in honor of Dian.  Let me tell you why.  Once she had a friend bring her a pie and she was very excited to taste it, naturally thinking it would be sweet.  But, this pie was an onion pie and it was quite shocking to the tastebuds.  But, I thought I would share with her ( and you) my recipe.  I think she might like this one, though she doesn’t eat pie crust or anything with lots of fat.  Hmmm…..

Now I use the term “my recipe” quite loosely because really, I took a recipe that I saw in Country Living Magazine and I changed it a bit to make it my own.  But, basically, it first belonged to a woman named Tandi Hauss.

I don’t think I have ever completely followed a recipe.  Most of the time, I see something that I don’t think will work to my liking or I don’t have all the ingredients and I know something I could use as a substitute.  Often, I just want to experiment.

Let me say that I almost always buy my pie crusts now in the canned biscuit section.  I only buy the kind you roll out, not the frozen one.  I think they are really good and so much easier than making it yourself.  But if you are a stockpiling or money saving mom, you will have to make your own crust.  Then cook it long enough to brown it…not too much but say half way cooked.

Also, my mother-in-law has fresh basil growing in her garden.  I normally plant some right outside the kitchen but never got around to it this year.  When you cut basil, it lasts longer if you put it in water like this:

Tomato and Onion Pie!

It also makes a nice arrangement.  However, you will need to either put it in the refrigerator or dry it for later.  You do that by preheating the oven to 200 degrees.  Wash the basil and dry really well, picking off all the leaves.  Place them in a single layer on a cookie sheet and dry in the oven for about 30 minutes. 

Tomato and Onion Pie!

You will have to just check it periodically.  It may take more or less time.  Then just turn off the oven and let it sit for a couple of hours.  When you use it in a recipe, remember that dried basil requires less in a recipe than fresh.  And, FYI, it doesn’t freeze well.  Seems to lose it’s flavor.  Grow one of these plants indoors and have fresh basil all the time.

So here is my version of Tandi’s recipe.

Tomato and Onion Pie!

Ingredients:

2 large tomatoes or 4 plum tomatoes

1 cup chopped onion (Texas 10/15 is the best)  Even though a red onion is in the photo….don’t use red.  It didn’t taste as good as a yellow onion.

2 tablespoon of fresh basil or 3/4 tsp of dried

2/3 cup mayonaise (not Miracle Whip!)

2/3 cup Parmesan Cheese or Romano or mixed (use the shredded)

1 1/3 cup Pepper Jack Cheese or Chedder Cheese

Salt and Pepper

1 medium Garlic pod minced or 1/8 tsp of garlic powder (But, if you love garlic, double this)

Cut one of your tomatoes in half.  Slice half of it thinly.  The other half and the other tomato should be cut in wedges…not too thick.  Remove the seeds from the wedges.  Place the slices on a paper towel to soak up some of the juices…knocking out the seeds from these as well.  The seeds will cause the pie to be too runny.

In a bowl, mix together the mayo, Parmesan and 1 cup of the Pepper Jack or Chedder and the garlic.

Layer half of the wedges in the bottom of the lightly browned pie shell.  Top with 1/2 cup of chopped onions and a little salt and pepper.  On top of this, put half of the cheese mixture.  This will have to be kind of blobbed on and spread as much as possible.  It won’t cover it but it won’t matter.

Then, layer it all a second time in the same order.  This time, try to blob the cheese mixture where it didn’t land the first time.

Top this with the remaining 1/3 cup of cheese and then lay the slices of tomatoes on top of this.

Bake at 350 degrees for 30-40 minutes.  Check it after 20 minutes to see if you need to cover the edges of the crust if it is getting too dark.   Mine did not and was ready in 30 minutes.

This is a good vegetarian meal, though it is not low fat…so…..eat at your own risk.  Enjoy!

  •  shares
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Flipboard
  • Twitter


Dian1

3 Comments

Comments

  1. Kristi at Spend Less and Save More says

    at

    Thanks for letting me know about your recipe link up!

    Reply
    • Dian says

      at

      Thanks for linking up!! Looks great! I will have to start cooking!
      Thanks again!
      Dian

      Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Tuesday’s Tasty Tidbits: Indian Fry Bread says:
    at

    […] time for my favorite time of the week to hang out with a couple of my favorite Bloggers. Dian, of Grocery Shop For Free, and Susan, of Permanent Posies are cooking it up and linking it up by sharing some of their […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More You Might Like:

An assortment of grocery items including canned goods, cereal, produce, and packaged foods spread across a kitchen counter—showing the mix of brand-name and budget-friendly options.

5 Things You’re Probably Overpaying For (and How to Stop)

A variety of fresh groceries and pantry staples—like lettuce, pasta, carrots, apples, and jars of sauce—arranged on a kitchen counter with a neutral-toned backdrop.

Budget Meals That Don’t Feel Cheap (Your Family Will Actually Want Seconds)

Fresh groceries including meats, canned goods, and produce arranged on a kitchen counter, ready for prepping multiple meals.

How to Stretch One Grocery Trip into 10+ Meals (Without Feeling Like You’re Eating the Same Thing)

How to Make Your Small Space Feel Huge with These Simple Hacks

Welcome to GSFF! I’m Dian, a wife of over 30 years, Mom to 4 grown kids… Read more about Dian and GSFF

 

Shop Printables

Printable tools to simplify your day.
Budgeting, meal planning, organizing — all in one place.

Browse Now →

Join the List

Get weekly tips, printable freebies, and first dibs on all the good stuff.

Sign Me Up →

This Week’s Freebie

Snag the featured printable of the week before it rotates!

Browse The Collection →

Popular on Pinterest

Zucchini Recipe

Zucchini Recipe

Dollar Tree Buys

Dollar Tree Buys

Spice Rack DIY

Spice Rack DIY

Upcycled Bottles

Upcycled Bottles

Follow on Pinterest

Get smart money tips, printables, and everyday wins — straight from Pinterest.

Follow Us on Pinterest

Dian is a mom of four grown children, Nana to 7 beautiful grands, wife of over 30 years to an amazing husband, social influencer, and blogger. I love all things gardening, saving money, tips & tricks to make life easier, ANY cool new gadget, and feeding my Reality TV addiction (it's real y'all, you have no idea!) Dian has been featured in person, in print, and on sites like Huff Post, CBSNews, Blog Talk Radio, NBC DFW, Babble, Woman's Day, All You Magazine, Super Market News, Clark, & Pinner's Conferences. Want to know more? Check out the full bio here!

Featured On

  • AFN
  • All You
  • CBS
  • Holly Homer Live
  • Huffpost
  • LCFG
  • NBC
  • NQS
  • PRNetwork
  • Project You
  • Savings
  • Supermarket News
  • Thread MB
  • UT Arlington
  • ValPak
  • Womens Money
  • CBS DFW
  • NBC5
  • Daily Moss
  • Savings Guides
  • Making Money
  • Gift Guides
  • DIY
  • Family Living
  • Recipes

GSFF Transparent© 2009–2025  GSFF All Rights Reserved.
No content on this site may be copied and reused in any form or fashion without express written permission.
Privacy Policy